Monday, April 27, 2009

Cellan-Jones YouTube football video takedown

Rory Cellan-Jones has been on the receiving end of a YouTube takedown and warning notice.
"For the second time in a year, I'm in trouble with YouTube - and finding out just how closely the video-sharing service is now policed for any whiff of copyright infringement.

Last year I received a warning that a video I had uploaded of my family playing in the park featured copyrighted material in the form of a Cat Stevens song, used as a backing track.

In that case it was allowed to remain on the site, although advertising appeared alongside my video, as a result of an agreement between Google and the record labels on "monetising" music videos.

But now a video I uploaded at the weekend has been deleted - and I've received a stiff warning that my whole account could be closed down if I fail to behave myself.

This time the copyright issue involved not music, but football. I'd visited one of the big matches of the weekend - Brentford v Exeter City - and uploaded exactly 37 seconds of action...

I'd somehow forgotten that the Football League are policing YouTube closely - and also assumed that they were looking out for material grabbed from the television, not a few frames of video shot from the crowd.

It looks as though my camera doesn't belong to me once I go through the turnstiles at a football ground. Maybe they should have the same signs that you get at cinemas, warning against the use of a video camera."

Friday, April 24, 2009

RealNetworks v Hollywood

More copyright fun in a Californian courtroom today as RealNetworks take on the movie industry on the DVD-ripping software battleground.
"Hollywood calls it "rent, rip and return" and contends it's one of the biggest technological threats to the movie industry's annual $20 billion DVD market - software that allows you to copy a film without paying for it.

On Friday, the showdown over the issue will take place in federal court in San Francisco, where an army of lawyers representing Hollywood will argue that RealNetworks Inc.'s DVD "ripper" is an illegal digital piracy tool.

The company, in turn, will say the $29.99 software that allows DVDs to be easily copied to computer hard drives is legitimate.

The same federal judge who shut down music-swapping site Napster in 2000 because of copyright violations will preside over the three-day trial, which is expected to cut to the heart of the same technological upheaval roiling Hollywood that forever changed the face of the music business."

This one on the surface looks a bit closer to the Universal v Sony VCR 'substantial non-infringing uses' case from way back in the 1980s than Napster or Grokster did. The Napster judge, Marilyn Hall Patel, is presiding over this one too and it will be worth watching.

Cory on the secret international world of copyright policymaking

Cory Doctorow has a wonderful polemic on the secret processes by which copyright policy gets made, as per the ongoing ACTA negotiations, and the unintended benefits that accrue to copyfighters as a result.
"I recently found myself debating the head of the British Phonographic Institute, our local equivalent of the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA). He's Britain's top lobbyist for the collapsing record industry, and he said a remarkable thing.

An audience member had just stood up and asked one of those rambling non-questions that are really just polemics, words to the effect of, "You people are so evil -- just look at the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement, it's full of bad things and it's all being negotiated in secret, away from public input. It's more corporate influence on government!"

And then Britain's top record industry lobbyist said the remarkable thing: "It's perfectly normal for this kind of treaty to be negotiated in private. There's nothing sinister going on at all." That's when I realized that the all-powerful entertainment lobby has developed advanced lobbyist's senility. Lost its tactical marbles. Lost its spine.

And I had to suppress a grin...

Back in 2003, I flew to Geneva for the first time, to attend the WIPO Standing Committee on Copyright and Related Rights (SCCR) negotiation on a proposal called "The Broadcast Treaty."...

This was new ground for EFF -- we'd never gone to the UN before, and we weren't sure what, if anything, we could do about this stuff...

Before all the shenanigans started, I had to tell this incredibly complicated story: "Here's this UN body you've never heard of. Here's this subcommittee of that body. Here's this insanely complicated copyright treaty they're working on, and here's this really difficult-to-grasp but vitally important thing it's going to do to the Internet."

After the shenanigans, the story got much simpler: "We went to Geneva to take part in this Internet treaty negotiation and they threw out our handouts, gamed the system to keep us out of the room, and shouted at us for writing down what they said."...

t wasn't always that way at WIPO, which is the birthplace of the WIPO Copyright Treaty (WCT) and the WIPO Performances and Phonograms Treaty (WPPT), collectively called the "Internet Treaties."...

But delivering expensive, corrosive privileges to entertainment companies is bad politics if you plan on getting re-elected. It only works well if all the negotiations take place in secret and no one gets to see the ugly, greedy horse-trading that happens behind the scenes...

The global furor over ACTA shows that every time the entertainment industry screws up the process so that only it gets a seat at the table, it emboldens our side. It sends supporters our way. It makes explaining the substantive points simpler -- "See, this is just like that stupid law everyone in New Zealand was protesting!" -- and it makes the entertainment industry look stupider.

You know what would probably get something done? If the record industry proposed a law through the front door, with public hearings, to find an equitable, simple way to get paid for the use of its material online. A blanket license, say, that users or ISPs could opt into in exchange for access to all the music that's already online, wherever and however they can find it.

Sure, some of the hardcore copyfighters would hate it -- it'd feel too much like a "music tax" for their taste, and they won't rest until the music companies have been killed in vengeance for all the bad stuff they've done since 1996 -- but it'd make the entertainment giants seem reasonable, and it would make anyone who disagreed with them seem unreasonable. They'd have the easy sell: "We want to stop suing your kids, but these crazy infohippies won't let us!"

But they won't be doing that any time soon. In early April, Howard Berman, the powerful Hollywood Congressman, held a town hall meeting on copyright to which he invited a bunch of entertainment industry goons -- and not one advocate for a more moderate copyright stance. Whatever comes out of that meeting, we'll always be able to drum up public opposition to it by making fun of the cowardly way it was convened.

So bring ACTA on, bring on copyright term extension in Europe, bring on the next version of Canada's DMCA, bring on more ridiculous proposals from secret negotiations. The more they act like mustache-twirling villains, the easier it'll be to bring them down."

ICETV v Nine

For a more sensible perspective on copyright look to the Icetv decision in the High Court of Australia earlier in the week. Copyright anoraks may remember that the broadcaster, Nine, had won in the appeal court in this dispute over copyright in TV schedules. Warwick Rothie has an interesting analysis.
"IceTV publishes an electronic tv program guide or schedule. The ABC and SBS provide their program schedules, but the commercial free-to-air networks refused. Mr Rilet sat down and watched 3 weeks of Channel 9 programming, writing down the time and title of each program. He then made up a program schedule ‘predicting over’ what would be broadcast. As the broadcast date neared, however, IceTV employees checked up to 3 other program guides and made corrections to the ‘predicted over’ guide as appropriate. (A summary of the changes made to 2 particular days can be found at [179 - 181] of Gummow, Hayne and Heydon JJ’s reasons.) Mr Rilet and IceTV presumably engaged in the same kind of work for the other commercial networks.

The High Court unanimously held that IceTV’s use of time and title information (’slivers’ in Bennett J’s evocative phrase at first instance) did not reproduce a substantial part of Nine’s copyright in [one or other programming schedule]. (It is necessary to be a bit vague here since, as in Feist, the alleged infringer mistakenly (as it now turns out) conceded copyright subsistence in something, to the evident frustration of all High Court judges.)

One thing the Court was unanimously agreed upon is that “copyright does not protect facts or information”, it protects forms of expression. See e.g. [28] per French CJ, Crennan and Kiefel JJ and [70] and [102] per Gummow, Hayne, Heydon JJ...

The judgments both bear strong indications that Australian copyright law should change track and follow the line pursued by the US Supreme Court in Feist.

Both judgments appear to affirm that copyright involves a balancing of the competing interests of creators (and owners) and users or the public.

The fun, or future controversies, begin in what follows.

For French CJ, Crennan and Kiefel JJ, there appears to be a different approach according to whether one is considering questions of originality and substantiality in connection with subsistence of copyright or in connection with infringement.

French CJ, Crennan and Kiefel JJ appear to consider that copyright will subsist so long as what is expressed (in a material form) originates from the author in the sense of not being copied from somewhere else. See [33] and [48].

Their Honours accepted that infringement fell to be tested by ascertaining whether or not the time and title information in IceTV’s guides was a substantial part of the relevant Nine program guide. This required consideration of “the degree of originality of the particular form of expression of the part [taken].” at [52]

Just because the part taken originated from the author did not necessarily make that part a substantial part of the original copyright work - “[o]riginality in the context of infringement has a broader aspect.” at [38].

The time and title information reproduced by IceTV did not require much in the way of mental effort at [42]. Its chronological arrangement was obvious and prosaic at [43].

According to their Honours at [54]:

the critical question is whether skill and labour was directed to the particular form of expression of the time and title information, including its chronological arrangement. The skill and labour devoted by Nine’s employees to programming decisions was not directed to the originality of the particular form of expression of the time and title information. The level of skill and labour required to express the time and title information was minimal[83]. That is not surprising, given that, as explained above, the particular form of expression of the time and title information is essentially dictated by the nature of that information."

It's a thoughtful decision and bears some study, the time for which is sadly unavailable to me today. Thanks to Neil Dunbar for the alert.

EU parliament extends copyright term

The EU parliament caved in to vested interests yesterday by voting to extend the term of copyright in sound recordings by 20 years.
"Charlie McCreevy, the EU’s Internal Market Commissioner, who proposed the copyright changes, said: “Some might argue that European creators are overprotected. Those who rely on copyright for their income would beg to differ. If artists stay in the music recording business because it pays to do so, consumers would enjoy more variety as a consequence.

“Europe’s performers often live a very precarious existence at the best of times. This proposal ensures that performers can, in their late life, recoup a share in the income they generate.”"

The Commission is very pleased even though, by the EU's own figures, more than four fifths of the revenues flowing from this decision will go directly to the music labels and the top earning artists like the smiling Cliff Richard in the Times report on the vote. And anyone with the faintest mathematical literacy and a basic understanding of compound interest and discounted cash flows can demonstrate that it will not increase the incentive to create new works. Mr McCreevy is a chartered accountant and former Irish finance minister of seven years standing. With a background that suggests he should understand the figures he is really difficult not to believe he is being more than a little disingenuous in his comments.

Maybe someone could get through to him and the Commission by telling them the story of the birthday song? In 1893 the Hill sisters published the music and lyrics of a song called "Good Morning to All" in their book of songs for younger kids (I vaguely recall it had an original enlightening title along the lines 'Songs for the kindergarten' but just to be sure, check out Kimbrew McLeod's terrific book, Freedom of Expression, for a more detailed account of the story and the precise title of the sisters' Hill book). The tune had been around for years and had been sung with a variety of lyrics like "good night to you all" and "happy New Year to all" etc. The little kids liked the song so much they started singing it at birthday parties and spontaneously made up the words "Happy Birthday to You...".

The Hill sisters didn't get round to registering the copyright (a requirement in the US in those days) in "Happy Birthday to You" - neither the tune nor the words of which were created by them remember - until 1935. But so began the successful commercial life of "Happy Birthday to You" the royalties and lawsuits on which have been flowing ever since.

TimeWarner (or technically speaking its predecessor company Warner Communications) acquired the rights to the song in the late 1980s and were quite pleased when the US Congress extended the term of copyright by 20 years a decade later. This means that, in the US, the birthday song can continue to contribute more than $1 million per annum to TimeWarner's bottom line until 2030, by which time the Cliff Richards of the world will have been wheeled out to the media studios again with the sad tales of impoverished pensioner musicians who desperately need the copyright term to be extended. And despite economic evidence indicating those same poor musicians will benefit only to the tune of €0.5 to €30 per year at best, the politicians will drool over the photo-opportunity with the celebrity du jour and roll out the extension carpet again. There is a lot of the Groundhog Day surreality about the copyright term policy story but maybe by the time of the next extension I might not even be able to mention said film in such a context. I'm really going to have to wean myself off the elixir of copyright. I'm not sure how much longer I can stand seeing the story repeat itself.

It is a sad indictment of the EU Commission and 371 EU parliamentarians (and 37 abstainers) that they have bought into the fantasy of term extension spun so successfully by the entertainment industry's pr machines. It's a big win for the wealthiest artists and the labels and a big loss for the other interested parties - the majority of musicians, new creators and the public.

Rice and UK may be implicated in released torture memos

The Times is reporting that:
"A week has passed since President Obama set a train in motion with the publication of secret memos to justify harsh interrogations by the CIA, and the White House appears to have lost control over its ultimate destination.

Fresh disclosures of declassified documents on Wednesday implicated a dozen senior officials in the Bush Administration, including Condoleezza Rice, as having approved techniques such as waterboarding — simulated drowning widely regarded as torture — on terrorist suspects."

and on the flawed decision making process that led to the Bush administration's authorisation of torture. In addition the paper suggests that the UK Foreign Secretary's efforts to withhold documents that allegedly constitute evidence of the UK's complicity in the torture of former Gunatanamo Bay detainee, Binyam Mohamed, are weakened by President Obama's release of the US torture memos.

Tuesday, April 21, 2009

Blackboard lose another round

Also from the Chronicle, in the latest preliminary ruling from the US patent office Blackboard has lost again. Desire2Learn are quietly pleased.
"Last week the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office issued a preliminary ruling rejecting all 57 claims in a software patent that Blackboard Inc. used to successfully sue rival Desire2Learn for infringement. But the long-running patent battle between the two providers of course-management software is far from over, and the re-examination process could drag on for years because of the many chances that Blackboard has to appeal."
This one has a long way to run yet but its pleasing to see another step in the right direction.

Students lose Turnitin appeal

From the Chronicle of HE: Students Lose, Fair Use Wins in Suit Targeting anti-Plagiarism Tool
"Students have suffered another defeat in their legal fight against the company that runs a plagiarism-detection tool popular among professors.

A federal appeals court last week affirmed a lower court’s decision that the Turnitin service does not violate the copyright of students, even though it stores digital copies of their essays in the database that the company uses to check works for academic dishonesty.

The opinion from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit “will be cheered by digital fair-use proponents,” says the E-Commerce and Tech Law blog."

Pamela Samuelson on the Google Book settlement

Pam Samuelson has an insightful analysis of the Google book settlement at O'Reilly Radar.
"

Google has scanned the texts of more than seven million books from major university research libraries for its Book Search initiative and processed the digitized copies to index their contents. Google allows users to download the entirety of these books if they are in the public domain (about 1 million of them are), but at this point makes available only “snippets” of relevant texts when the books are still in copyright unless the copyright owner has agreed to allow more to be displayed.

In the fall of 2005, the Authors Guild, which then had about 8000 members, and five publishers sued Google for copyright infringement. Google argued that its scanning, indexing, and snippet-providing was a fair and non-infringing use because it promoted wider public access to books and because Google would take out of the Book Search corpus any digitized books whose rights holders objected to their inclusion. Many copyright professionals expected the Authors Guild v. Google case to be the most important fair use case of the 21st century.

This column argues that the proposed settlement of this lawsuit is a privately negotiated compulsory license primarily designed to monetize millions of orphan works. It will benefit Google and certain authors and publishers, but it is questionable whether the authors of most books in the corpus (the “dead souls” to which the title refers) would agree that the settling authors and publishers will truly represent their interests when setting terms for access to the Book Search corpus...

In the short run, the Google Book Search settlement will unquestionably bring about greater access to books collected by major research libraries over the years. But it is very worrisome that this agreement, which was negotiated in secret by Google and a few lawyers working for the Authors Guild and AAP (who will, by the way, get up to $45.5 million in fees for their work on the settlement—more than all of the authors combined!), will create two complementary monopolies with exclusive rights over a research corpus of this magnitude. Monopolies are prone to engage in many abuses.

The Book Search agreement is not really a settlement of a dispute over whether scanning books to index them is fair use. It is a major restructuring of the book industry’s future without meaningful government oversight. The market for digitized orphan books could be competitive, but will not be if this settlement is approved as is."

ACTA threat to the future of WIPO

Michael Geist has been suggesting that ACTA may well be a response to the increasing emphasis on the development agenda at WIPO.

Google Book settlement faces legal assault

Also missed this recently: Google Book settlement faces legal assault

Monday, April 20, 2009

Winona Rider or Osama Bin Laden - face scanners can't tell

I missed this a couple of weeks ago. The trial of the face scanning technology at Manchester Airport caused long queues, so they re-calibrated it to let more people through without the extra security checks triggered by a scanner alert. Similar scanners at Sydney Airport set to the same calibration level were tested by an academic from Glasgow University and were unable to tell the difference between Osama Bin Laden and actress Winona Rider. The Home Office is, however, insisting that "Previous tests show that they system can reliably pick out imposters and even distinguish between identical twins."

Friday, April 03, 2009

Radiohead manager Brian Message to testify for Tenenbaum

Via Glyn on the ORG list: Radiohead manager Brian Message has reportedly agreed to testify for student Joel Tenenbaum in the case being brought against him by Sony BMG, alleging he used Kazaa for the illicit copying of 7 songs. Charles Nesson of Harvard's Berkman Center is leading Tenenbaum's defence.

Thursday, April 02, 2009

IPRED implemented in Sweden

The Swedish law implementing the EU's Intellectual Property Rights Enforcement Directive of 2004, officially came into force yesterday, according to a CNet report. And the vice chairman of the Swedish Pirate party is reported by the BBC as suggesting it has instantly cut Net traffic in Sweden by 33%.

Wednesday, April 01, 2009

ACTA timeline

Michael Geist has posted a very useful ACTA timeline on his blog.

Update: Via Glyn Moody, see also Geist's article in the Ottawa Citizen, Battle over top-secret treaty heats up
"Next week, the Department of Foreign Affairs will conduct one of the stranger consultations in recent memory. Officials have invited roughly 70 stakeholder groups to discuss an international intellectual property treaty that the U.S. regards as a national security secret and about which the only substantive information has come from a series of unofficial leaks.

Since then-minister David Emerson announced Canada's participation in the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement negotiations in October 2007, the ACTA has been dogged by controversy over the near-total lack of transparency."

Slideshare rockstar?

I just had an email from Slideshare telling me I'm a "Slideshare RockStar". Apparently the slides of my talk at the Westminster eForum on on copyright last year have been getting a lot of views in the past 24 hours. Sure enough, on checking, it seems that it has been viewed more than 10,000 times. I assume there is probably a simple explanation for this (is there, Tony H.?) because I'm not aware of anything that should have suddenly pushed traffic in that direction recently. It's not really been a big IP news week.

Is this an April fool's joke?

Smith and the adult films - nothing to hide nothing to fear

Simon Jenkins is in good form at the Guardian today, pleased that the Home Secretary has been hoist by her own petard, after the revelations of her husband's porn watching and her subsequent claiming for the cost of it on expenses.
"Sweet is the spectacle of a home secretary bitten by her own snake. The outrage of Jacqui Smith's television expenses claim lies not in its content, lurid as it is, but in the way it was exposed. How many times must the home secretary have been assured in security briefings that her latest purchase of some data storage gizmo was "totally secure"?

"Don't worry," the briefers would have said, "the material will be protected by the finest firewalls, the most foolproof anti-hacking devices and the most savage legal defence. Nothing will be transferable and only the highest in the land will have access. Besides, home secretary, as you have so often said, the innocent have nothing to fear."

Yes, they do. They have the revelation of their husband's taste in movies, apparently leaked by contractors in receipt of easily copied discs, now on offer to anyone with £300,000...

In the last eight years, the same MPs who are howling at their data vulnerability have voted for the most extensive surveillance system in Europe, as well as the biggest data storage in the most expensive and inept computers. Britain under Labour has become the world capital of privacy intrusion...

In 2000, just nine organisations were allowed warrants to access secure government records: the figure is now almost 800. For a small fee, anyone will be able to learn anything about anyone else. It may be illegal, but like computer downloads it will happen...

One of the few home secretaries who dominated his department rather than be cowed by it was Lord Whitelaw in the 1980s. He boasted how after any security lapse, the police would come to beg for new and draconian powers. He laughed and sent them packing, saying only a bunch of softies would erode British liberty to give themselves an easier job. He said they laughed in return and remarked that "it was worth a try".

Now the try always works. What is extraordinary is the weakness of the liberty lobby in opposition...

The only hope is that now MPs... might be more mindful of the liberties - and privacies - of others. I would not hold my breath."

Opposition to Authors Guild on Kindle 2 text to speech

Manon Ress notes that there is growing opposition to the Authors' Guild stance which caused Amazon to shut off the text to speech feature of its Kindle 2 ebook reader.
" Reading disabled persons affected by the Authors’ Guild request to remove the text to speech function on Kindle 2 include include school children, the elderly, professionals, university students, returning veterans, and yes, your neighbors, family members and friends.

The Reading Rights coalition is growing and includes now 22 members:
American Association of People with Disabilities
American Council of the Blind
American Foundation for the Blind
Arc of the United States and United Cerebral Palsy
Association of Blind Citizens
AHEAD (Association on Higher Education and Disability)
Bazelon Center for Mental Health Law
Burton Blatt Institute
DAISY Consortium
Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund (DREDF)
IDEAL Group, Inc.
International Center for Disability Resources on the Internet (ICDRI)
International Dyslexia Association
International Dyslexia Association – New York Branch Learning Disabilities
Jewish Guild for the Blind
Knowledge Ecology International (KEI)
Learning Disabilities Association of America
National Center for Learning Disabilities
National Disability Rights Network
National Federation of the Blind
NISH (formerly National Institute for the Severely Handicapped)
National Spinal Cord Injury Association

Equal and not separate Reading Rights

What we believe:

“As technology advances and more books move from hard-copy print to electronic formats, people with print disabilities deserve the opportunity to enjoy access to books on an equal basis with those who can read print.”

People with print disabilities cannot effectively read print because of a visual, physical, perceptual, developmental, cognitive, or learning disability.

Simply put, people with reading disabilities want to buy books. They are fighting to have equal access to technology and information.

Now that the Kindle 2 offers text-to-speech, some reading disabled persons could actually purchase and enjoy books at the same time as anybody else.

However, it looks as if the Authors Guild does not support equal access for those willing to pay equal prices. For the Guild, to read books, reading disabled persons must either be “registred” or pay more to read with text-to-speech.

Here is an Open Letter to Authors by the Reading Rights Coalition.

And here is a powerful statement from Carrie Russel, Director Program on Public Access to Information, ALA Office for Information Technology Policy

“It is hard to know what is worse — Amazon cowtowing to the Authors Guild’s request to remove the text to speech function or the Authors Guild seeking to squeeze every penny they can from the visually impaired who are already paying for the Kindle books. Amazon did not have to cave - there was no license they had agreed to with the Authors Guild to remove the speech function that would have expanded rights to private reading. Shame on the Authors Guild for being greedy and downright mean to the visually impaired.”

Please support us, people with reading disabilities and people who care about access to books for all, by joining an informational picket in front of the Authors Guild’s headquarters in downtown Manhattan on April 7, 2009 at 12:00 p.m."

EU Consumer Commissioner focuses on online privacy

The EU's Commissioner for Consumer Affairs, Meglena Kuneva, yesterday turned her attention to matters of online data collection and profiling.
"We are here to talk about one of the most important and most controversial issues in the fast evolving world of digital communications: the explosion in the volume of collected personal data and its use for commercial purposes.

I feel there is a much needed discussion on the new generation of practices and business models built on the ability to profile consumers and then use their profile to target them for commercial purposes...

Internet is an advertisement supported service and the development of marketing based on profiling and personal data is what makes it go round. Personal data is the new oil of the internet and the new currency of the digital world...

Tools must now be developed that balance the interests of business with that of the consumers. This means two things: the respect of users' right to control their public exposure; and the obligation to protect them against abusive and risky practices targeted at them.

We have already well established consumer policy principles, articulated in regulations and tools that bring confidence in the traditional world of goods and services. These are principles of transparency, clear information, choice, fair commercial communications and fair contract terms. We do not need to reinvent the wheel. What we need now is a debate on how we apply these tested principles in digital world, in particular in the activity of collecting consumers' personal data for the purpose of commercially targeting them...

Our research shows that young people between the ages of 15-25, the most confident of internet users, use the internet in spite of the fact that they generally don’t trust it. Using internet under these conditions is like drinking your water while thinking it might be slightly toxic. We would not allow such a situation to exist in the market for water, or cosmetics or toys. We do not tolerate this lack of confidence in any consumer commercial setting because in the long run lack of confidence damages markets. In our toxic water example, you will drink the toxic water but you will drink just enough and no more. And the water market will not thrive.

There are three particular strands of actions we must address: privacy policies, commercial communications and commercial discrimination...

More than 4 out of 5 young internet users believe that their personal information is somehow used without their knowledge and shared with third parties without their agreement. They are right...

The status quo is not an option. Currently, consumers have little awareness of what data is being collected, how and when it is being collected and what it is used for. And they are also not able to control this process. The current opt-out systems are partial, sometimes nowhere to be found, they are difficult or cumbersome and most of all, they are unstable. Avoiding tracking is currently technically difficult if not impossible...

We must establish the principles of transparency, clear language, opt-in or opt-out options that are meaningful and easy to use. I am talking about the right to have a stable contract and the right to withdraw. And I am also talking about fair clauses and the right to participate in economic activity without selling your whole self indiscriminately as commercial fodder to the entire world...

No one in the digital space really cares about our actual names or exact physical addresses. What traders want is a description of who we are and a way to reach us. They want to know that the person behind the number 1234 is young, sporty, drives fast cars and travels frequently and that as a trader you can show up on his screen at your convenience. This is fine. But what about the person behind number 456, unemployed, in debt and about to lose his home? He is a target for predatory loans and fraudulent financial and yes, personal, advice...

But we must ensure that commercial communications comply with the law. This means they cannot deceive, mislead or amount to excessive pressure. What is the implication of these principles in a world of personal information?

...

This actually brings us the really tricky matter of the blurring of commercial and non commercial communications. A recent experiment in neuroscience suggests that individuals might abdicate their own valuation of risks when given individual advice by an expert and just follow the expert's advice. [1] This only reinforces the need to enforce the principle of identifying commercially sponsored messages and, even more importantly, the principle of identifying commercially sponsored messengers.

The situation becomes even trickier in the world of social sites and viral marketing. Young people and even children are being particularly targeted as conduits for advertisement. If a toy company incites a little girl to share with her friends she got a brand new doll, is the message she sends an advertisement? Does receiving a sponsored message that your best friend got a doll amount to pressure selling if you are 7 years old?

Our current legislation forbids advertisements that ask children to pester their parents but we say nothing of the ones that ask them to pester their friends...

If this personal information is used to extract the maximum price possible from you or to block your access to some services altogether, then commercial discrimination can damage the confidence in digital trade and services. People may resent a world where they would have to systematically pay for who they are or the risks they personally incur.

Excessive targeting in the form of price or commercial discrimination can also inhibit the ability of users to predict and compare prices which seriously harms competitiveness in a market.

We have some way to go to understand the full consequences of this commercial practice but we must start thinking about the parameters for legitimate discrimination. What type of commercial discrimination, if any, is damaging to consumer trust and market efficiency?

...

I invite industry to develop a framework that applies consumer policy principles and that will establish the principles of acceptable behaviour...

The regulatory protection we have in Europe is extensive and far-reaching. There is a huge task ahead of us in terms of enforcement of the rules that already exist both regarding privacy and consumer protection. Some progress has been made but it is not nearly enough...

Behavioural targeting on the internet will become increasingly pervasive and consumers understandably feel uncomfortable.

Today I want to send one very clear message to those involved in all aspects of the digital world - Consumer rights must adapt to technology, not be crushed by it. The current situation with regard to privacy, profiling and targeting is not satisfactory.

The central issue is to transpose the principles of consumer policy to this new technological reality so that we maintain our traditional boundaries of what is right and what is not, what damages people and markets and what favours and nurtures them...

If we fail to see an adequate response to consumers concerns on the issue of data collection and profiling, as a regulator, we will not shy away from our duties nor wait for a cataclysm to wake us up."

I wonder what she means by the phrase "Consumer rights must adapt to technology"? Surely whoever wrote her speech really meant to say that technology should be used in ways that respect consumer rights?

Friday, March 27, 2009

Google and Privacy International clash again

From the Guardian:
"Google has dismissed accusations that it is orchestrating "an unsavoury and defamatory smear campaign" in the increasingly ferocious battle with the campaign group Privacy International, which claims the technology giant is trying to discredit its concerns over the controversial Street View tool.

In an open letter to Google chief executive Eric Schmidt tonight, Privacy International's director Simon Davies claims that after it had raising a series of privacy concerns in the national press, Google staff began secretly briefing journalists against the group by alleging it is supported by and institutionally biased in favour of Microsoft."

EU Parliament report rejects 3 strikes

Via Michael Geist on Twitter European Parliament Rejects Three Strikes and You're Out Approach

I see Slashdot has picked it up too. The report is available at the europa website. Michael Geist says:
"The key paragraph states that the Parliament recommends that the European Council:

proceed to the adoption of the directive on criminal measures aimed at the enforcement of intellectual property rights, following an assessment, in the light of contemporary innovation research, of the extent to which it is necessary and proportionate, and while simultaneously prohibiting, in pursuit of that purpose, the systematic monitoring and surveillance of all users’ activities on the Internet, and ensuring that the penalties are proportionate to the infringements committed; within this context, also respect the freedom of expression and association of individual users and combat the incentives for cyber-violations of intellectual property rights, including certain excessive access restrictions placed by intellectual property holders themselves;

While this is a mouthful, it is noteworthy that the Parliament emphasizes proportionality, the rejection of Internet monitoring, and the use of excessive access restrictions placed by IP rights holders."

Thursday, March 26, 2009

Security flaws halt work on ContactPoint

From the Times: Security flaws halt work on ContactPoint
"Security flaws have halted work on the internet database designed to hold the details of 11 million children and teenagers.

The Department for Children, Schools and Families (DCSF) admitted last night that it had uncovered problems in the system for shielding details of an estimated 55,000 vulnerable children.

These include children who are victims of domestic violence, those in difficult adoptions or witness protection programmes and the children of the rich and famous, whose whereabouts may need to be kept secret.

ContactPoint is a £224 million online database that contains the names, addresses, dates of birth and details of schools, GPs, social workers and support services of all 11 million people aged under 18 in England. It is intended to improve child protection...

Some adopted children whose identities should be shielded are listed on the database by both their original and their adopted surnames, with a link between the two."

"In other instances, shielding simply disappears from the records of vulnerable children every time that the database is updated automatically from central government databases, such as the school census or the child benefit database. "

As Rights Clash on YouTube, Some Music Vanishes

From the NYT: As Rights Clash on YouTube, Some Music Vanishes
"In early December, Juliet Weybret, a high school sophomore and aspiring rock star from Lodi, Calif., recorded a video of herself playing the piano and singing “Winter Wonderland,” and she posted it on YouTube.

Weeks later, she received an e-mail message from YouTube: her video was being removed “as a result of a third-party notification by the Warner Music Group,” which owns the copyright to the Christmas carol.

Hers is not an isolated case. Countless other amateurs have been ensnared in a dispute between Warner Music and YouTube, which is owned by Google. The conflict centers on how much Warner should be paid for the use of its copyrighted works — its music videos — but has grown to include other material produced by amateurs that may also run afoul of copyright law.

“Thousands of videos disappeared,” said Fred von Lohmann, staff lawyer for the Electronic Frontier Foundation, an Internet civil liberties group that asked affected YouTube users to contact it. “Either they turned off the audio, or they pulled the video.”"

Obama administration sides with RIAA in P2P suit

Declan McCullagh tells us that the Obama administration has sided with the RIAA in the Joel Tenenbaum P2P lawsuit:
"The Obama administration has sided with the recording industry in a copyright lawsuit against an alleged peer-to-peer pirate, a move that echoes arguments previously made by the Bush administration.

A legal brief filed Sunday in a case that the Recording Industry Association of America is pursuing in Massachusetts argues that federal copyright law is not so overly broad and its penalties not so unduly severe that they count as "punitive." Current law allows a copyright holder to receive up to $150,000 in damages per violation...

The Massachusetts case could prove to be an important one. A group of Harvard law school students, with the help of Harvard law Professor Charles Nesson, is providing defendant Joel Tenenbaum with an aggressive legal defense. They aim to convince the courts that the law the RIAA relies on is so Draconian it amounts to "essentially a criminal statute" and is therefore unconstitutional; that it grants too much authority to copyright holders; and that it violates due process rights guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution."

New Zealand scrap 3 strikes provision

The New Zealand government has reportedly scrapped the three strikes provision (Section 92A) of the Copyright Amendment (New Technologies) Act.

Minister rules out use of evoting machines in Ireland

The Irish minister for the environment has reportedly ruled out using the Nedap evoting machines that have been gathering dust in a warehouse in Ireland at the cost of more than a few euros per annum.

Friday, March 20, 2009

OGC finally publish the Gateway Reviews of the ID Cards system

From the ever informative SpyBlog:"

The Office of Government Commerce, an Agency of Her Majesty's Treasury, has finally publish the two Stage Zero Gateway Reviews of the ID Cards programme

It has taken- 1510 days i.e. 4 years 1 month 18 days after the initial Freedom of Information Act request, which should, according to the law, and the principle of "open government" and public transparency, have taken no more than "20 working days".

The OGC has spent at least £120,000 on legal fees alone, and probably a similar amount of public money again has been spent by the Information Commissioner's Office and the Information Tribunal.

See the OGC FOIA disclosure page.

Here are the two documents, which were kept so secret, that the OGC initially refused to let even the Information Commissioner have copies of them.

Here are the documents which caused the Government to invoke the Bill of Rights 1689 against the Information Tribunal's first decision to support the Information Commissioner''s decision to permit full disclosure.

Both the information Tribunals decided to redact or censor the names of the Assessors doing the Gateway Reviews,and the names of the people who were interviewed about the project.

Here is some early commentary and analysis:

Thursday, March 19, 2009

Strategic Advisory Board for IP priorities for copyright

In the thick of other things I missed the Strategic Advisory Board for Intellectual Property Policy's (SABIP) publication last week of a very clear paper setting out its priorities for its copyright work programme. It identifies an interesting set of issues and actions:
"1. The role of copyright in stimulating creativity
and innovation...

SABIP will investigate how different types of copyright law7
enhance or reduce creative output. Does the system assist
creators in earning appropriate rewards, notwithstanding the
apparently widespread illegal and unpaid-for dissemination
of products? SABIP will analyse differences in returns
to stakeholders within national copyright frameworks of
varying approaches and will further explore the implications
of technologies of mass copying and distribution on these
returns. Is the existing system equipped to respond
appropriately to the effects of the new technologies?

...

2. Ownership and coverage of copyright...

SABIP will undertake research into alternative approaches
to copyright coverage which distinguish between
economic and moral rights and their potential advantages
and disadvantages. SABIP may, for example, conduct
comparative studies of copyright legislation in other
countries where the respective emphasis on moral and
economic rights differs from that in the UK. Notwithstanding
the diffi culties of effecting change within the context of the
relevant internationally binding treaties and agreements,
SABIP will also consider the likely economic and social
impact of potential changes in the law...

3. Rights management techniques and technologies...

SABIP will review the effects on the various parties
(creators, publishers and other providers, professional and
other users) of the adoption of Digital Rights Management
(DRM) Tools. In doing this, SABIP will explore sectoral
differences and the effect of external deterrents or any
barriers on take-up. SABIP will seek to identify the patterns
of use of DRM tools, their individual benefi ts and weaknesses
and their overall implications for various stakeholders...

4. The relation between copyright and contract...

SABIP will examine the relative effects of copyright law,
contract law and DRM/TPM technologies on incentives,
distribution of fi nancial rewards and the protection of user
freedoms. Do standard form contracts limit or hinder user
freedoms in particular creative sectors? SABIP’s research
programme may also explore evidence around claims that
creators lose out in the negotiation over contract terms.
SABIP will compare how legal models used elsewhere offer
protection to creators’ economic interests and moral rights.
In the light of this analysis it will consider whether there is a
case for amendment to the balance of UK copyright law in its
relation with contract law and how such a change could be
implemented...

5. Simplifi cation of the copyright framework...

SABIP will investigate the perceived and/or actual
drawbacks of current copyright law in terms of its
complexity. For example, which provisions are narrowly
defi ned and therefore not relevant or comprehensible or
which boundaries of exceptions are unclear or confusing?
What impact does this complexity have on willing compliance
by users?
SABIP will consider what, if any, specific steps would
benefi cially simplify the law and rationalise the provisions
of the 1988 Act regarding copyright, in order that it is
widely accessible and comprehensible, as well as being
appropriately enforceable by those whose legitimate
interests are undermined by breaches of copyright.

6. Attitudes & Behaviours in the Digital Economy:
Implications for IP...

SABIP will: continue to explore the relationship between
the general understanding of the copyright framework and
compliance with the copyright framework; the extent to
which this framework is felt to be “fair”; effective means of
education as to copyright rights and responsibilities; and
the effectiveness of current or prospective enforcement
techniques. For example, SABIP will investigate whether
new types of content producer are aware of the copyright
protections available to them, and whether they are able to
deploy the system effectively.
The first phase of this project, a literature review, is due to
be completed in April this year. The fi ndings of the review
will be presented at a stakeholder workshop that will
contribute to the development of a large-scale consumer
survey into attitudes and behaviours in the digital economy
and their implications for Intellectual Property."
The hugely positive aspect of all of these research proposals is that they are firmly rooted in the notion of generating empirical data and analysis to inform policymaking. Each one of the six proposals is potentially a huge undertaking on its own if they are to be done properly, so hopefully SABIP have the substantive funding to support them. SABIP are planning to make their first substantive evidence-based policy recommendations within the next 12 months. Evidence-based intellectual property policy making - now that would be a paradigm shift! They are also inviting comments on the scope of their proposals.
"The Board and its Expert Panel will be developing plans for
undertaking this work programme over the coming months. This
process is intended to include both face-to-face discussions and
opportunities for written presentations on each of the specific areas
outlined in this paper. Any comments should be sent to info@sabip.
org.uk. most usefully by the end of May 2009."

Mixed news on copyright

There is some mixed news on copyright today. Firstly it seems that the Internet Service Providers' Association of Ireland (ISPAI) have rejected the demands of the music industry for a 3 strikes regime in Ireland, despite the recent Eircom settlement.
"This [threatened] legal action is spurious and there is no evidence of wrong-doing by Internet service providers... These actions could impact on user privacy, damage the development of new Internet services, and hurt Ireland's standing as an e-commerce hub."...

The statement added that ISPAI could not ignore the protection of privacy of user communications in Irish and European law "merely because it does not suit another private party.""
Next up the EU parliament has, according to ORG, postponed the vote on copyright term extension that was due to take place on 23 March.
"Amid intense lobbying in the European Parliament next Monday’s vote on the proposal to extend the term of copyright has been struck off in a shock move. Following a meeting of the presidents of the political groups in the European Parliament on Tuesday, and with controversy and a lack of consensus surrounding the proposal, MEPs have delayed voting till the end of April - just before this summer’s European elections. A trialogue discussion between the European Commission, Council and Parliament, set for the end of March, will now attempt to broker a deal to see if the directive will be allowed to pass.

MEPs are waking up to the reality that the proposal to extend copyright term doesn’t do what it says. It’s a terrible and unworkable instrument that will do nothing but bring copyright into disrepute in the eyes of consumers. If you’re concerned about the need for a fair and balanced copyright framework you must contact your MEPs now. Make your voice heard!

In other news this week Professor Martin Kretschmer, Director of the Centre for Intellectual Property Policy & Management Bournmemouth, and Horace Trubridge, Assistant General Secretary of the British Musicians’ Union, have been debating the copyright term extension proposal. Additionally copyright creators in the Association for Fair Audiovisual Copyright in Europe have launched a petition against the proposal.

But right now the most important thing is to contact your MEPs and tell them why copyright term extension is a bad idea! Use our web banners and spread the word."

Also from ORG: A Digital Rights Agency: “an industry owned, industry led and industry run body”

"Last Thursday the Open Rights Group along with many others made a submission in response to the Digital Britain Report. In that submission, we said:

This action has the potential for much harm. We call on the final Digital Britain report to
reject the idea of a ʻrights agencyʼ.

Less than 12 hours later, we found David Lammy and Stephen Carter launching a consultation into the shape of the ‘Digital Rights Agency’.

It is hard to believe that either minister had processed the responses on exactly this question in the space of twelve hours. More concerning still is the comment in this new document from Lammy and Carter that:

“fundamentally this has to be an industry owned, industry led and industry run body.”

This is precisely the problem we have with the idea of a Digital Rights Agency. Rather than working out what a legitimate and balanced future of copyright and enforcement looks like, the problem gets handed over to the people most worried about enforcement. This is what we wrote in our submission which no doubt Lammy and Carter were busy reading over breakfast:

The proposal seems to be at heart a way of extending the MoU process without a clear idea of how to resolve the underlying problems.

Overall, we doubt that a rights agency would be able to adequately reflect users and citizenʼs rights, have a tight remit and offer value for money.

We have emphasised that any agency would have to include representatives of consumer interests, so that concerns such as protection of the innocent, and preservation of privacy are given proper weight. We would not wish the role of defending customers to be filled by ISPs alone, especially as many of them are also rights holders, with conflicting business interests.

There are other key stake holders who would need to be represented, including at least Consumer Focus, UK Online Centres and the Information Commissionerʼs Office. However, because of the nature of such an agencyʼs work, we are equally sure that non-statutory groups would likely be very cautious about engaging in its work.

A rights agency we assume would be in effect a semi judicial process, with a duty to co-ordinate enforcement of sanctions below the level of court action. While there may be merit in, for instance, overseeing the nature of letters sent to consumers, there are also potential problems. A ʻrights agencyʼ could quickly be involved in inappropriate attempts define a range of sanctions below the level of court action.

A ʻrights agencyʼ could easily be a body whose functions quickly sprawl, especially under pressure from rights holders if their business models continue to change too slowly to meet market demands.

From a public perception point of view, innocent consumers would be paying through their broadband bills for the enforcement of third party rights. This doesnʼt seem like a wise option for a government looking for public consent.

You can add your own public comments on the proposal for a Digital Rights Agency here."

Mark Thomas DNA removed from police database

Also writing in the Guardian, comedian Mark Thomas tells us he has managed to arrange to have his DNA and fingerprints removed from police records. The police agreed to remove his details after he had threatened to issue judicial review proceedings, in the wake of the Home Secretary's lack of substantive response to the European Court of Human Rights ruling against the UK government in December (S. and Marper v The UK).
"Until Tuesday I was one of 800,000 innocent people in the UK who had their DNA on the police database. Most of us had a swab sample taken on arrest and our identifiable cell clusters have languished on police files even if charges were dropped or we were found not guilty in court.

In 2003 I was arrested at a protest against the arms dealer BAE Systems and charged with causing £80 worth of damage to a bus. Leaving aside the irony that if any BAE Systems products only caused £80 of damage the purchasers would sue for a refund, seven months later I found myself on trial. After two days I was acquitted on the legal technicality of being innocent. More important, the court found there was no evidence for a crime having been committed in the first place. The experience left me frustrated, with only a 20-minute comedy routine to take away the pain of injustice...

On Tuesday the police replied with one line: "I can confirm that a decision has been made to delete your client's fingerprints and DNA sample and DNA profile." No explanation why.

Victory celebrations, though, might be premature. As the law remains unchanged it leaves the onus on individuals to write to the police seeking removal. Helen Wallace, from the NGO GeneWatch, says she has received "copies of letters from lots of individuals who have not been convicted of any offence who are being refused removal from the database". As Jacqui Smith has dodged the issue it is up to us. There are 799,999 of you out there, mostly pissed off, some eligible for legal aid, and everyone with the motivation to do their bit in rolling back the data state. Go on, write in."

I assume the suspected sewer grating photographer, Stephen Clarke, will have taken note. Mark Thomas may not have had to go as far as a judicial review - presumably whoever got the job of reviewing his request for removal noted he was an outspoken comedian who would definitely pursue the issue and took the necessary pragmatic decision in order to avoid expensive and publicly embarrassing litigiation - but I expect one of the 800,000 or so will eventually take it before a judge.

Minister seeks power to approve school textbooks

According to the Guardian, the government is now seeking the power for ministers to specify which authors' works would go on the school curriculum.
"The schools secretary, Ed Balls, is seeking a new legal power to dictate the basic content of every public exam in England, in a move that would give him or any future secretary of state the right to decide which books children must study at GCSE or A-level.

The law would allow the government to set "minimum requirements" for qualifications. One senior exam board source said it would give ministers "mind-boggling power" over exams if it got on to the statute books.

Opposition MPs will attempt today to remove from the apprenticeships, skills, children and learning bill the clause that gives the secretary of state control of basic qualifications content. Guidance published alongside the bill says it could be used to specify "which authors' works needed to be studied for someone to gain a GCSE in English".

Ministers insist the power would be exercised only as a last resort, to preserve the teaching of Shakespeare, for example, if there was a suggestion it should be scrapped from the curriculum."

What's worrying is that some of them probably even believe that bit about saving Shakespeare.

Wednesday, March 18, 2009

Copyright term again

Less than a week now until the EU Parliament votes on the latest copyright term extension proposals and I'm reminded, naturally, of Jefferson and Macaulay but also, more recently, a lecture by Sir Hugh Laddie in 1995 (the IP Institute Stephen Stewart Lecture), subsequently published in the European Intellectual Property Review journal the following year (Laddie, H. (1996), "Copyright: over-strength, over-regulated, over-rated?", European Intellectual Property Review, Vol. 18 No.5, pp.253-60.) Discussing the then relatively new EU copyright term extension directive of 1993, Laddie had this to say:
"As a result of the Term Directive, the copyright in the first category of works, that is to say, literary works and so on, is now life of the author plus 70 full years. This additional 20 years has been imposed throughout the Member States of the European Union to bring us into line with the domestic law of Germany. As is now familiar in copyright law, the process was one of leveling up the protection rather than levelling down. The result of this new term is that if, for example, a young computer programmer writes a new piece of computer software, he generates a monopoly which will normally last for over 100 years. Depending on his longevity, it may last more than 150 years. Similarly, if a politician writes letters or speeches which are of general historic interest, they also may be protected for a century or more. Indeed, if a modern-day architect were to design a new Albert Memorial, he would have the satisfaction of knowing that his copyright is likely to be sprightly and in the prime of life long after the concrete and steel of his architectural creation have started to crumble.

The question to be asked is: what justification is there for a period of monopoly of such proportions? It surely cannot be based on the principle of encouraging artistic creativity by increasing the size of the carrot. No one is going to be more inclined to write computer programs or speeches, compose music or design buildings because 50, 60 or 70 years after his death a distant relative whom he has never met might still be getting royalties. It is noticeable that this expansion of term is not something which has only occurred in the last decade. On the contrary, it has been a trend which has been in evidence for the whole of this century. Before the 1911 Act, the term of copyright in artistic works extended to seven years after the author's death. In 1911 this was extended to 50 years after death. The growth of term is in fact greater than these figures suggest. Life expectancy in 1910 was far shorter than it is now. The result is that a monopoly which was expected to last about four decades in 1910 should now be expected to last on average more than three times as long.

Indeed, I believe that the same criticism of excessive duration can be leveled at the 50-year flat term which applies to films, recordings and broadcasts. It may be possible to pick out a few creations of exceptional artistic or commercial merit where one could argue for lengthy protection - for example, the recordings of Rostropovich or the Beatles - but is it right that all copyright should be protected on the basis of what might be thought justified for the exceptional few? Furthermore, it is possible to argue that these long copyright terms are not necessary to protect the commercial exploitation of the works themselves. Most works protected by copyright are exploited very rapidly, if at all. This is so whether we are considering films and records or literary works such as computer software. Even books such as those that win the Booker prize are only commercially successful for a short time and then, to all intents and purposes, pass away. Yet the dead hand of copyright lingers on, in most cases serving no useful purpose.

Another of the problems with copyright law is that, unlike inventions protected by patent or designs protected by registration, the requirements for qualification are so low as to be virtually non-existent. Virtually any written material, any sketch and any film footage or sound recording is automatically protected. This has practical consequences. In Elanco v Mandops, the Court of Appeal accepted, as it had to, that a label of instructions placed on the side of a barrel of herbicide was a copyright literary work. No doubt depending on the youth of the literary genius who wrote it, the label will be protected for more than a century and perhaps for as long as a century and a half - certainly well beyond the date when for safety or commercial reasons the product has been removed from the market. So one of the troubles with copyright, then, is that it springs up to protect nearly every creation of the human mind, be it ever so trivial. As another member of the judiciary put it, the fact that our system of communication, teaching and entertainment does not grind to a standstill is in large part due to the fact that in most cases infringement of copyright has, historically, been ignored...

It would be possible to go on criticising the width of our copyright laws, but perhaps I have said enough. It might be more useful to inquire why our law has developed as it has. I have mentioned already the value and size of the industries which now believe they need extensive copyright protection to safeguard their income stream. They, quite properly, lobby for their interests. But who lobbies against them? There is no trade union of copyright infringers. Support for any limitation on copyright is easily portrayed as support for pirates - the usual pejorative global expression for infringers. It is depicted as support for the parasites of industry. Is it surprising, then, that the scope of protection gets ever wider? I suggest that the drafting of the legislation bears all the hallmarks of a complacent certainty that wider copyright protection is morally and economically justified. But is it?"
Laddie, who died in November last year, was widely respected round the world as an IP litigator, judge (he was a High Court judge between 1995 and 2005) and educator (Prof at ICL). It would be sad if the EU were to ignore his and countless other renowned IP experts advice and press ahead with this ill conceived measure.

Tuesday, March 17, 2009

Report on Kingsnorth climate camp policing

From BritCit Blog:

Lib Dem MP David Howarth has been highlighting the disturbing treatment of peaceful protestors by police at a climate camp in August last year.


"Government justified the heavy-handed approach by revealing that 70 police officers had been injured policing the protest; but a freedom of information request revealed that these 'injuries to police' included such things as heatstroke, toothache and insect bites. Vernon Coaker, the Home Office minister who had made the claim about police injuries, was later forced to apolgise to the House and admit that "there were no recorded injuries to police officers sustained as a result of direct contact with the protestors".

Here are the links to the report and appendices:

Sadly if you prime a large body of police to expect trouble and send them into an area where people are gathering for some event, you can't be surprised with the predictable results. The resultant inevitable conflict does a disservice to dedicated police officers and the general public, stoking up tension, suspicion and lack of trust, when a stable democracy requires mutual respect between the two.

Maybe if the headline chasing politicians, wanting to claim they are cracking down on criminality and terrorism, were charged with reckless disregard for public safety, every time they engineered this kind of clash, there would be more responsible decision making in the higher echelons of government and the police service? I wonder if the attempts by the government to smear the protestors after the event would be actionable under the UK's defamation laws (assuming some of these claims were specific enough and made outside the cloak of parliamentary privilege)?

Ironically even the minister's attempt to backpedal was not entirely accurate - he said in his letter to David Howarth:
"Kent police have informed the Home Office that there were no recorded injuries to police officers sustained as a result of direct contact with the protestors."
Yet Appendix 1 of the report lists 4 incidences of police officers' bruising as a result of "Assault by another person".

Schneier on privacy and data toxicity

Bruce Schneier has been writing eloquently about privacy again.
"Welcome to the future, where everything about you is saved. A future where your actions are recorded, your movements are tracked, and your conversations are no longer ephemeral. A future brought to you not by some 1984-like dystopia, but by the natural tendencies of computers to produce data.

Data is the pollution of the information age. It's a natural byproduct of every computer-mediated interaction. It stays around forever, unless it's disposed of. It is valuable when reused, but it must be done carefully. Otherwise, its after effects are toxic.

And just as 100 years ago people ignored pollution in our rush to build the Industrial Age, today we're ignoring data in our rush to build the Information Age...

Society works precisely because conversation is ephemeral; because people forget, and because people don't have to justify every word they utter.

Conversation is not the same thing as correspondence. Words uttered in haste over morning coffee, whether spoken in a coffee shop or thumbed on a BlackBerry, are not official correspondence. A data pattern indicating "terrorist tendencies" is no substitute for a real investigation. Being constantly scrutinized undermines our social norms; furthermore, it's creepy. Privacy isn't just about having something to hide; it's a basic right that has enormous value to democracy, liberty, and our humanity.

We're not going to stop the march of technology, just as we cannot un-invent the automobile or the coal furnace. We spent the industrial age relying on fossil fuels that polluted our air and transformed our climate. Now we are working to address the consequences. (While still using said fossil fuels, of course.) This time around, maybe we can be a little more proactive.

Just as we look back at the beginning of the previous century and shake our heads at how people could ignore the pollution they caused, future generations will look back at us -- living in the early decades of the information age -- and judge our solutions to the proliferation of data.

We must, all of us together, start discussing this major societal change and what it means. And we must work out a way to create a future that our grandchildren will be proud of."

Monday, March 16, 2009

Students blog important environmental trial

Now here's a valuable way to use computers in education: Student bloggers give public a seat at Grace trial
"A cadre of journalism and law students from the University of Montana is providing a virtual window on what many are calling the most extensive environmental criminal trial in U.S. history.

Paired together in two-hour shifts, a law student and a journalism student provide daily, continuously updated online coverage of the W.R. Grace & Co. trial in U.S. District Court in Missoula through their blog, http://blog.umt.edu/gracecase.

Communities in Montana and around the country were exposed to asbestos-contaminated ore that W.R. Grace mined and shipped from Libby, Mont. Lawyers for Libby residents contend the pollution has killed some 225 people and sickened about 2,000 in Libby.

Now, W.R. Grace and five former company officials face criminal charges of knowingly endangering lives by hiding the health risks of asbestos."

Amazon DMCAs vendor of ebooks for Kindle

According to Declan McCullagh Amazon has threatened to sue MobileRead.com under the DMCA to stop the latter company making available electronic books that could be read on the Amazon Kindle ebook reader.
"This week, an e-book Web site said Amazon.com invoked the 1998 law to prevent books from some non-Amazon sources from working on its Kindle reader.

Amazon sent a legal notice to MobileRead.com complaining that information relating to a computer utility written in the Python programming language "constitutes a violation" of the DMCA, according to a copy of the warning letter that the site posted. MobileRead.com is an e-book news and community site.

MobileRead.com forum moderator Alexander Turcic said in a post on Thursday that although he did not believe the program violated the law, the site would "voluntarily follow their request and remove links and detailed instructions related to it." Turcic said that, contrary to Amazon's claim, his site never "hosted" the software.

Amazon did not respond to a request for comment on Friday."

As ever IP-land is like groundhog day - same story repeated over and over with some variations. Shades here of Apple v RealNetworks ("ethics of the hacker...breaking into the iPod" etc. - Apple loves and extensively threatens the DMCA from iPods to iPhones), Lexmark v Static Control (blocking competitor selling cheap printer cartridges for Lexmark printers), and Chamberlain Group v Skylink (the DMCA and garage door openers).

Friday, March 13, 2009

Law Lord: government sanctioned illegal surveillance

Via Nicholas Bohm on the ukcrypto list, comes a link to a fascinating decision from the House of Lords this week on the surveillance of lawyers' discussions with their clients facilitated by the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act, 2000. Lord Phillips, dissenting from the majority view, says:
"The appeal raises... two issues of general importance:

i) What impact, if any, does the Regulation of Investigatory
Powers Act 2000 (“RIPA”) have on the common law right
of legal professional privilege (“LPP”)?
ii) What impact, if any, does RIPA have on the right accorded
by a number of statutory provisions of a person detained in
a police station or in prison to consult a lawyer privately?

52. On 30 November 2007 the Divisional Court held that monitoring
of legal consultations in police stations or prison cannot lawfully be
authorised under the Code in its present form. The reaction of the
Secretary of State to that finding was made clear by Mr Fordham in his
written case on her behalf. This was that, contrary to the decision of the
Divisional Court, the Code covered consultations between legal advisers
and their clients. I quote from paragraph 7(4)(5) that case:

“(4) The safeguards contained within RIPA and the Code
are sufficient to ensure, in the case of directed surveillance
in both of the relevant factual scenarios, the requisite
quality of law to satisfy the Art. 8 requirement “in
accordance with the law”.

(5) The Secretary of State nevertheless recognises the
sensitivities that surround the possible use of directed
surveillance in the two factual contexts at issue, and has
carefully considered the Divisional Court’s concern
regarding the adequacy of the safeguards that would apply
at the point when any such directed surveillance was
authorised. The Secretary of State would wish to make
clear at the outset that, as a matter of policy, she considers
it desirable to take the steps necessary to remedy the
concern identified by the Divisional Court. In effect,
directed surveillance of legal consultations in detention
would fall to be assimilated to “intrusive surveillance” for
the purpose of prior authorisation. That could readily and
properly be achieved by an order under RIPA s. 47(1)(b)
characterising as “intrusive”, surveillance in locations
where it is known that consultations are taking place
between detainees and their legal advisers.”

53. This stance was not satisfactory. The Divisional Court did not
express concern. It made a finding of law against the Secretary of State.
She chose not to appeal against that finding. In those circumstances it
was not open to her to consider as a matter of policy whether to “take
the steps necessary to remedy the concern identified by the Divisional
Court”. The position was simply that unless and until she took the
appropriate steps she could not lawfully continue to carry out
surveillance on legal consultations in prisons or police stations..."
Baroness Hale however, reluctantly says:
"67. I agree, for the reasons given by my noble and learned friends
Lord Hope of Craighead and Lord Carswell, that RIPA does permit
the covert surveillance of communications between lawyers and their
clients, even though these may be covered by legal professional
privilege and notwithstanding the various statutory rights of people
in custody to consult privately with their lawyers. This is an
unpalatable conclusion, but one to which I am driven both by the
plain words of the Act and by the history of legislation on this
subject."
Lord Carswell:
"92. The appellants have brought this appeal in order to challenge the
finding of the majority of the Divisional Court that RIPA was
intended to extend to legal or medical consultations...
The Secretary of State has, however, stated
that she is willing to make an order under section 47(1)(b) of RIPA
characterising surveillance of consultations between detainees and
their legal advisers as intrusive surveillance, with the safeguards
which go with that level of surveillance. If done, this would make
consideration of directed surveillance of such consultations
superfluous. It is regrettable, however, that no step has yet been
taken to make the necessary order, notwithstanding the fact that the
present practice was declared unlawful over a year ago, and no
appeal was brought against the court’s decision. Having said this, I
do not propose to enter into further discussion of the proportionality
of directed surveillance of legal or medical consultations, save to say
that I agree with the conclusion reached by the Divisional Court...

100. I commence with the wording of RIPA. In its natural and
ordinary sense it is capable of applying to privileged consultations
and there is nothing in its wording which would operate to exclude
them... It seems to me unlikely that the
possibility of RIPA applying to privileged consultations could have
passed unnoticed. On the contrary, it is an obvious application of the
Act, yet no provision was put in to exclude them.

105. I conclude accordingly that Parliament intended that the covert
surveillance provisions of RIPA should extend to the type of
lawyer/client and doctor/patient consultations which are ordinarily
protected by legal professional privilege."
Lord Neuberger:
"106. In my view, Part II of the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act
2000 (“RIPA”) permits covert surveillance of communications and
consultations between a person in custody and his or her lawyer,
notwithstanding that such communications enjoy legal professional
privilege, and despite such a person’s statutory right to consult a
solicitor privately."
[...]

108. If covert surveillance is carried out in accordance with Part II of
RIPA, the natural meaning of the opening words of section 27(1) is
that, whatever rights would otherwise be infringed thereby, the
surveillance is nonetheless lawful. As Lord Phillips’s admirable
survey of the law demonstrates, this case involves two rights, which
are different, but very closely connected, namely the right of a
person to consult a lawyer in private, and the right to legal
professional privilege in connection with communications with one’s
lawyer. Any modern civilised legal system recognises the
fundamental importance of these two rights, and therefore one feels
an instinctive initial reluctance to hold that section 27(1) permits
covert surveillance of such consultations and communications, as it
would appear significantly to undermine such important rights.
109. However, while these two rights are very important, neither can
possibly be regarded as unqualified. Both rights can self-evidently
be abused for improper, even criminal, purposes; indeed, as a result
of such abuse, the rights themselves could fall into disrepute...

111. It must be acknowledged that there are two inherent paradoxical
problems in the exercise of intercepting or listening in on privileged
communications and private consultations between lawyer and
client. First, the authorities cannot know if the privilege and right to
privacy are being abused and that the iniquity exception applies,
until the interception or listening in has occurred and its results
examined. Secondly, the authorities cannot warn the parties in
advance that interception or listening in will or will not occur, as to
do so would defeat the whole point of the exercise. Further, it is selfevident
that knowing that a consultation or communication may be
the subject of surveillance could have a chilling effect on the
openness which should govern communications between lawyer and
client, and is the very basis of the two rights. However, none of these
problems can call into question the lawfulness of the statutory
authorising of the surveillance of privileged communications,
although they underline the fundamental requirement of clear and
stringent rules governing the authorisation, circumstances, manner,
and control over the fruits, of any such surveillance.

112. Accordingly, there is nothing intrinsically objectionable in a
statute which authorises surveillance of communications and
consultations between a lawyer and client, provided that the statute
includes safeguards which ensure that such authorisation complies in
all respects with the requirements of the Convention. Additionally, I
see no reason why the safeguards cannot be in a Code of Practice, at
least if the statute provides that such a code has to be created and
complied with (as is the position here – see sections 71 and 72 of
RIPA); that is all the more true where, as here, the code has to be
laid before Parliament...

118. Lord Phillips has characterised the nature of the decision of the
majority of your Lordships as being that RIPA permits the Code to
authorise surveillance of communications between lawyers and their
clients, whether or not in custody. That is indeed as far as our
decision in this case goes, and we should not, I think, be taken as
thereby endorsing the provisions of the Code, as we are not directly
concerned with those provisions, and, in particular, whether they
comply with the requirements of the Convention. Indeed, in my
view, it must be highly questionable whether the Code sufficiently
clearly identifies (or limits) either the circumstances in which
surveillance may or may not occur, or how the information thereby
obtained may or may not be used. At least as at present advised I
share the doubts and concerns about the Code expressed by Lord
Phillips at paras 49 to 51. The question of the use of material
obtained by surveillance could have arisen in one of the cases before
us, namely that of M, had he not been released without charge, and,
in that connection, I agree with Baroness Hale’s observations at
paras 71to 74.

119. I also respectfully agree with what Lord Phillips says at paras 52
and 53. Having decided not to appeal the Divisional Court’s decision
that surveillance of privileged and private consultations under the
present regime is unlawful, the Secretary of State should have
ensured that such surveillance did not take place or she should have
promptly changed the regime so as to comply with the Divisional
Court’s decision. As Lord Carswell points out, more than a year has
elapsed since that decision, and your Lordships were told that the
Secretary of State was not even in a position to produce a draft
regulation embodying the changes to ensure that such surveillance
was carried out legally. Unless no surveillance of privileged and
private consultations has been going on for the past year in the
United Kingdom (which appears most unlikely), this strongly
suggests that the Government has been knowingly sanctioning illegal
surveillance for more than a year. If that is indeed so, to describe
such a state of affairs as “regrettable” strikes me as an
understatement."
So RIPA can facilitate surveillance of privileged consultations between solicitors and clients but only under carefully regulated conditions which should be specified in the RIPA Code of practice, which in turn would make it compliant with the European Convention on human rights. Though it wasn't a question for the Lords in this instance, however, the Code was declared not compliant with the Convention by the Divisional Court a year ago and so, Lord Neuberger says, the government has probably been "knowingly sanctioning illegal surveillance for more than a year" and government suggestions that such a state of affairs is "regrettable" strikes him as an "understatement."

Translating from law-lord-ese he's basically saying the Secretary of State has been outrageously incompetent in not getting the RIPA Code put in order.