Wednesday, October 28, 2026

Meta/Facebook v New Mexico decision

Last week, Santa Fe District Court judge, Frances J. Matthew, fined Meta $219,498.6 billion which he reduced to $25 billion, after a jury found Meta liable for misleading consumers about the safety of its platforms and endangering children, earlier this year.

The judgment is only 20 pages, very accessible and worth reading in full. 

Some of the highlights:

 

 

 

 

 

 Following the Cambridge Analytica scandal in March of 2018 Facebook promised a comprehensive review to

 

32. ...The decision was deliberately made to narrow Facebook's internal definition of data misuse so that Facebook would not have to notify as many people due to the operational burden of doing so. That decision was never communicated to users, despite the very public promise to notify in all cases of misuse.

 

 

 

 

 

 

The judge then notes that the US Supreme Court has not said that the 8th amendment to the constitution, preventing government from imposing excessive fines, applies to corporations. So,  

 

 

 

 

 

 

It is an unequivocal judgment against Facebook and an indictment of the unethical behaviour of their senior people.

The only thing the judge doesn't explain is why he reduced the penalty from $219 billion to $25 billion. 

Facebook are appealing the decision but are not out of the woods on US lawsuits by a long shot. The Florida attorney general, James Uthmeier, has condemned the multi-state settlement in the case that both New Mexico and Florida pulled out of and declared that "Florida isn't going to sell out to Meta."

Amongst other lawsuits against Meta/Facebook re. Facebook, Inc. Securities Litigation which has been making its way through the courts since 2018, over the Cambridge Analytica cover up, may prove to be the most significant. The latest list of Facebook witnesses the plaintiffs want to call is striking and includes Zuckerberg, Sandberg, Nix, Bosworth, Chancellor, Kogan, Kaplan, Wylie, Pricewaterhouse Coopers and Sarah Wynn-Williams, the author of Careless People.

 

 

 

 

Update: Daphne Keller offers a useful close read of the parallel Meta child safety settlement with most of the US states, plus the TikTok settlement with Alabama "intended as a functional resource for people... to more easily check settlement details and reach their own conclusions. It links to annotated copies of the settlements themselves, a comparison table, and a doc full of AI answers about weedier questions."